Cord Hollister is a true cowboy at heart. As a man who has devoted his life to training horses under the big skies of Montana, he thrives on the stability of ranch life. But when a girl arrives in Painted Pony Creek with a shocking secret, Cord's orderly life is upended. She's the spitting image of the first woman who broke his heart--a woman he hasn't seen in years--and he'll do whatever he can to help her. He just can't do it alone. Shallie Fletcher...

Heading to Blue River, Texas, to gain employment as a marshal, Sawyer McKettrick instead finds himself at the mercy of a prim and proper lady with a gun who is the only one who can tame his wild heart.

When he arrives in Stone Creek to start a new life, reformed rustler and train robber Wyatt Yarbro sets his sights on prim and proper Sarah Tamlin who, unbeknownst to Wyatt, is harboring her own dark secret.